Henter beholdningsoplysninger
Detaljer om materialet
Type
Cd (musik)
Format
1 cd i bog, hybrid SACD
Genre
klassiske symfonier
Emneord
Emnetal
78.411
Bidragsydere
Beskrivelse
Live-optagelse, Philharmonie Berlin 22.-23. marts 2017
Forlag
Berlin Phil Media
Målgruppe
voksenmaterialer
Anmeldelser
Fono Forum, 2019 August
"CDs des Monats: Diese Wiedergabe erhält eine dramatische Spannung ... Petrenko erzählt straff und zielgerichtet ... , in den schnellen Sätzen spielt das Orchester mit nahezu unheimlicher Präzision, in den langsamen Teilen lassen die Musiker eine Lust am Reichtum und an der Fülle von Klangfarben erkennen ... Das ist fesselnd, packend und berührend"
The gramophone, 2019 July
"Editor's choice: It seems churlish to complain of short measure when so much more of the symphony can be heard than on most rival versions ... This is unapologetically German-sounding Tchaikovsky, albeit sung with a strong Russian accent ... I came away from it not wrung out ... but ever more humbled in the face of a masterpiece"
BBC music magazine, 2019 September
"Is it possible for a performance ... to be recorded too well? ... The sound is so stunningly present, so perfectly tailored ... Details are amazing, for which I'm grateful, but sometimes they only add to a feeling of technical precision ... But I can imagine listeners who are bowled over by this perfection"
Presto classical, 2019-05-17
"Recording of the week: The first movement unfolds with an almost Classical restraint ... Petrenko may have learned his craft in the opera-house, but no smell of greasepaint lingers in the atmosphere of this recording ... It's in the final few pages, though, that Petrenko's understated sincerity is most overwhelming in its emotional impact"
Presto classical, 2019-05-17
Diapason, 2019 été
Vurdering: 4/5
MusicWeb international, 2019 June
"Recommended: Petrenko and his Berliner Philharmoniker produce an array of emotions that can leave the listener crushed. Under Petrenko the orchestra play throughout with total commitment and power when needed. Together with impressive reserves of energy, they produce a gripping sense of deep emotional engagement ... I've not heard a finer performance of the 'Pathétique' than this from Petrenko and the Berliner Philharmoniker, which goes right to the top of the pile. Unquestionably, this is very special recording!"
MusicWeb international, 2019 June